Judah Goldin Seminars, 1999-present
Welcome.
The Judah Goldin Seminar is a forum for graduate students in Biblical, Postbiblical and ancient Near Eastern studies, hosted by the Department of Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations at the University of Pennsylvania. Graduate students, and visiting professors, present the results of their scholarship in an informal, supportive, and scholarly environment. This archive contains the abstracts of these presentations.
The concept for this forum was developed and initiated by our distinguished Professor Jeffrey H. Tigay in 1999. He continues to support it and nurture the young scholars who participate. We are proud that the seminar was named in honor of Professor Judah Goldin, admired and beloved by students and colleagues, who was Professor of Postbiblical Hebrew Literature at Penn. The proceedings of the 1999 symposium in memory of him is available. Click here.
We invite you to share these abstracts, and some longer articles.
HEBREW BIBLE
Spencer Allen, "Finding President Clinton in the Bible: A Typological Study of the book of Samuel"
Spencer Allen, "Understanding Amos 6:12 in Light of his other Rhetorical Questions"
Spencer Allen, "Bruce Springsteen and the Puritan Ideal of the Promised Land" and "Mary Queen of Arkansas, Mary Queen of Heaven"
Spencer Allen, "The Concept of Fate in Megillat Esther"
Spencer Allen, "The Ishtars of Hammurabi's Prologue: The Issue of Divine Multiplicity"
Shawn Aster, "Divine Radiance in the Book of Job"
Shawn Aster, "The Excavations at Jezreel and the Symbolism of Jezreel in Hosea 1-2"
Shawn Aster, "Royal Ideology in Ancient Israel: Psalm 21 in its Northwest Semitic Context"
David Gilad, "Ezra the Scribe/Priest in Ancient and Modern Theological Discourse"
Shalom Holtz, "The Thematic Unity of Psalm 144 in Light of Mesopotamian Royal
Ideology"
Shalom Holtz, "Ancient Near Eastern Visions of Prosperity and the Unity of Psalm 144"
V. Kerry Inman, "Text Criticism of the Hebrew Bible and the Ancient and Immediate Versions"
Yehuda Kraut, "The Literary Role of Reuben and Judah in the Book of Genesis"
Yehudah Kraut, "Deciphering the "Shema": A New Approach to Deuteronomy 6:4"
Yehuda Kraut, "The Birds and the Babes: the Structure and Meaning of Psalm 8"
Kevin McGeough, discussion of I. Finkelstein and N.A. Silberman's The Bible Unearthed
Jacob Milgrom (Professor Emeritus, University of California - Berkeley), "The Mishkan: The Priestly 'Picture of Dorian Gray'"
Stephan Reif (Director of Genizah Research and Professor of Medieval Hebrew at Cambridge University), the use of Geniza materials for Biblical Studies
Dalit Rom-Shiloni, "The Role of God in Victory and Defeat: A Multifaceted Biblical Debate in the Sixth Century BCE"
Dalit Rom-Shiloni, "Theodicy,
or Better 'Theodical Discourse': A Case for Hebrew Bible Theology"
Aliza Schachter, "Princess as Political Pawn"
Andrea Weiss, "Metaphor in the Prose Narratives of I & II Samuel"
Susan Zeelander, "Discerning Biblical Religion, methodology of Professor Stephen A. Geller"
Susan Zeelander, "Inner-biblical Polemics and Psalm 50"
Susan Zeelander, "Ritual Endings in Short Narratives in Genesis"
Bill Zimmerle, "Second Impressions: The Iconography of Hebrew Seals"
ANCIENT NEAR EAST
Tzvi Abusch (Brandeis), "The Wild Man, the Courtesan, and the Hunter in the Epic of Gilgamesh" and "Graduate Workshop on Mesopotamian Witchcraft Literature"
Rachel Anisfeld
Miroslav Barta, Visiting Lecturer in Egyptology (visiting from the Czech Republic). "Sinuhe, the Bible, and the Patriarchs"
Paul Delnero, "Textual Criticism and Sumerian Literature"
Shalom Holtz, "To Go and Marry any Man that You Please: The History of a Legal Idiom"
Shalom Holtz, "Judiciary in Mesopotamia During the Period of Persian Domination"
V. K. Inman,
"The Origins of the Afroasiatic Languages"
Josh Jeffers, "Fifth Campaign Reliefs in Sennacherib's 'Palace Without
Rival' at Nineveh"
Steve Kim, "Semitic N-Stem"
Stephen Kim, "Thoru-Ilu, the Fertility God of Ugarit"
Stephen Kim, "Traveling Gods in Ancient Syria-Palestine"
Shannon Martino, "Alternate Representational Systems: Vinca Cultural Priorities from the 6th- mid 4th millennium B.C."
Kevin McGeough, "Late Bronze Age Administration: Keeping Track of People"
Jeremie Peterson, "Sumerian Animal Terms in their Concrete Contexts"
Bezalel Porten (Hebrew University),"The Peregrinations of a Peripatetic Papyrologist"
Benjamin Porter, "Learning from Washpots: Production, Authority, and Social Life in the Iron Age I Southern Levant"
Matthew Rutz, "The Problem of Fakes and Forgeries in the Study of the Ancient Near East"
Matthew Rutz, The Origins of the Alphabet
Matthew Rutz, "The Stele in and out of Cultic Contexts in Bronze Age Syria: Signs of Authority at Emar and Ekalte"
Karen Sonik, "The Dragon-Green, the Luminous, the Dark, the Serpent-Haunted Sea: Tikva Frymer-Kensky's Non-Domesticated Woman"
Karen Sonik, "Parables of Kingship: A Literary Text in Ritual Context"
Ran Zadok (Tel-Aviv University), "Connections Between Babylonia and Elam in the Chaldean and Achaemenid Periods"
POST-BIBLICAL
Menahem Ben Sasson (Hebrew University), "The Un-Finished Story of the Keter (A Few Chapters from the History of the Aleppo Codex)"
Michael Carasik, "Translating the Miqra'ot Gedolot into English" (since published as "The Commentators Bible, Exodus")
Naftali Cohn, "The Earliest Rabbis and Their Claim for Authority: An Analysis of the Ritual Narrative Genre in the Mishnah"
Michael Sokoloff (Bar Ilan University), "Computerized Lexicography: The Jewish Aramaic Dialects of The First Millennium C.E."
ADVICE TO GRADUATE STUDENTS
Nili Fox (Associate Professor of Bible, Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion, Cincinnati) Academic Life Beyond the Dissertation
| Spencer Allen |
"Finding President Clinton in the Bible: A Typological Study of the book of Samuel" |
allen2@ccat.sas.upenn.edu |
A number of parallel events in the lives of King David and President
Bill Clinton form the basis for a comparison between the two, with
David's life serving as the type for interpreting Clinton's life. This
tongue-in-cheek paper models the type-antitype form of interpretation, which was used in early Christian writings (e.g., the Passion Narratives and Galatians 3-4) and in the American self-image (e.g., topological names and the concept of the "New Israel"), as a pedagogical tool. |
| November 3, 2004 |
top
| Spencer Allen |
"Understanding Amos 6:12 in Light of his Other Rhetorical Questions " |
allen2@ccat.sas.upenn.edu |
The MT of Amos vi 12a comprises a pair of rhetorical questions: "Do horses run on the rock(s)? Or does one plow with oxen?" An analysis of Amos' other pairs of rhetorical questions, which demonstrate a high degree of semantic and structural parallelism, suggests that the MT is corrupt. Four criteria are accordingly derived from these other rhetorical questions to evaluate the numerous proposed solutions for vi 12a. Alan Cooper's emendation is identified as the most consistent with Amos' general usage: "Do horses run on crags? Or does the wild ox plow in the valley?" |
| November 15, 2005 |
| Spencer Allen |
"Bruce Springsteen and the Puritan Ideal of the Promised Land" |
allen2@ccat.sas.upenn.edu |
In 1641, John Cotton defined the "carnall man," born through Adam's fall, as one who "never served any man but himselfe." Envisioning New England as their Promised Land, where participation in God's covenant could restore an Edenic paradise, the Puritans' religious ideology revolved around the individual's striving to fulfill his covenantal duty, vocational hard work on behalf of the common good. Achieving this, he would receive the luscious fruits of New Israel in such measure that "the Fields and Woods are died red" (Denton, 1670) (cf: Numbers 13:23).
This same Puritan work ethic informs much of Springsteen's corpus: the woman of "From Small Things?" serves only herself and so loses her way to the Promised Land, while the immigrants of "Galveston Bay" and "Across the Border" work towards the common good and will one day "eat the fruit from the vine" supplied by "God's blessed waters" in the Promised Land. |
| September 7, 2005 |
top
| Spencer Allen |
"Mary Queen of Arkansas, Mary Queen of Heaven" |
allen2@ccat.sas.upenn.edu |
In contrasting Springsteen's relationship with "Queen Mary" in the first three years (1972-1975) of his career with the most recent (2002-2005), we obtain both a cross-section of religious development from cynical youthfulness to a more devout adulthood and a sense of how deeply he integrates "the self-communication of God in secular life with the overarching symbol/narratives of his [Catholic] tradition" (Greeley, 1988).
In the work of his early twenties, Mary was a prostitute, unworthy of trust (If I Were the Priest; Mary, Queen of Arkansas), who drained life from those who loved her (Thunder Road). Realizing he himself possessed nothing that could transform her, he offered flight as a means of achieving a new life and freedom. In maturity, their roles have reversed: Mary is now a most trustworthy partner (Reno) who brings the singer life and a sense of "home" (Maria?'s Bed) by accepting everything he is. |
| September 7, 2005 |
| Spencer Allen |
"The Concept of Fate in Megillat Esther" |
allen2@ccat.sas.upenn.edu |
The few religious events that occur in the MT Esther narrative emphasize the significant differences between the Jewish and pagan actors and their God/gods without ever referring to the divine. These include two pagan events, the lots casting in Esther 3:7 and Zeresh's omen explanation to Haman in 6:13, and two Jewish references, the fasting in 4:1-3 and Esther's new reason to fast in 4:16-17. The difference between these two groups lies in their ability to petition the divine to change the outcome. Haman and his cohorts believe they can derive the will and knowledge of the gods through their interpretation of omens; however, they never act to change the anticipated outcomes by petitioning their gods. Mordecai and the Jews, in contrast, do involve themselves in religious activities that suggest they believe they can petition their deity to change their future. While Esther believes God will provide an escape, Haman cannot cling to any explicit hope from his gods but simply accepts that the die is cast. |
| May 1, 2003 |
top
| Spencer Allen |
"The Ishtars of Hammurabi's Prologue: The Issue of Divine Multiplicity" |
allen2@ccat.sas.upenn.edu |
In the prologue to Hammurabi's law collection, the divine name Ishtar appears at least six times, five of these times in association with specific geographical locations, while a sixth occurrence places her in a context specifically appropriate to Babylon. Further, in two of these five occurrences, the Ishtar referred to is partnered with a different god. No other divine name is similarly treated in Hammurabi's prologue. This unique repetition of the Ishtar divine name in the prologue's context, coupled with the specific geographical locales associated with five of the six references and the two different spouse names, suggests that we are dealing here not with six manifestations of a single goddess, but rather, unexpectedly, with a multiplicity of distinct and independent deities. |
| March 19, 2008 |
| Shawn Aster |
"The Excavations at Jezreel and the Symbolism of Jezreel in Hosea 1-2" |
sza@sas.upenn.edu |
| In the first two chapters of Hosea, "Jezreel" is used as a referent for both Jehu's rebellion against Ahab's house and the coming destruction of Israel's might. It is clear why Jezreel should be used to symbolize Jehu's rebellion, but why should it serve as a symbol for Israel's might? The excavations at Jezreel suggest that the site had a military role in the 9th-8th centuries. This function might help explain the use of the name in Hosea. My paper will expose the rhetorical and literary function of the term "Jezreel" in Hosea, discuss the dating of Hosea 1-2 and examine whether the recent publication of the material from Tel Jezreel is useful in understanding the verses containing this name in Hosea 1-2. |
| November 13, 2003 |
top
top
| David Gilad |
"Ezra the Scribe/Priest in Ancient and Modern Theological Discourse" |
dgilad@bgu.ac.il |
| While modern scholarship has not arrived at definitive conclusions regarding Ezra's mission and legacy, the figure of Ezra has played a significant theological role in all three major monotheistic religions. One finds a great variety of theological perceptions of Ezra in many ancient sources, including the apocryphal literature, rabbinic literature, and the writings of church fathers and classical Islamic historians. In these sources, Ezra is variously presented as a proto-rabbinic sage, as a prophetic spokesman for either the Jewish remnant community or for the early church, or as a malicious forger of scriptures. Ezra's theological significance has continued to be debated in post-Renaissance scholarship, beginning with Spinoza, continuing through Wellhausen and his school, and culminating with a number of contemporary liberal minded biblicists and critical Talmudic scholars. |
| April 1, 2008 |
| Shalom Holtz |
"The Thematic Unity of Psalm 144 in Light of Mesopotamian Royal
Ideology" |
holtz@sas.upenn.edu |
| Psalm 144 combines a prayer for assistance in battle (verses 1-11)
with a description of the nation's prosperity (verses 12-15). The
combination of these two parts parallels several examples from Mesopotamian
royal literature that combine depictions of the king as a heroic warrior with portrayals of the king as a provider of prosperity. The combination of these themes in Mesopotamian sources sheds light on the question of the thematic unity of Psalm 144. The psalm, which many consider to be a "royal
psalm," is an Israelite expression of a royal ideology similar to that known from Mesopotamia. [Forthcoming in VT] |
| |
| Shalom Holtz |
"Ancient Near Eastern Visions of Prosperity and the Unity of Psalm 144" |
holtz@sas.upenn.edu |
| This paper will present a survey of some Akkadian and Hebrew descriptions of a prosperous realm under the rule of a king. Using the results of this survey, the presentation will then address the text-critical questions of Psalm 144, specifically, the combination of the two parts of the psalm. |
| |
| V. Kerry Inman |
"Text Criticism of the Hebrew Bible and the Ancient and Immediate Versions" |
inmanvk@sas.upenn.edu |
| The ancient and immediate versions are of particular use in textual criticism of the Hebrew Bible. By this is meant those translations which were made directly from the Hebrew text at an early stage such as Jerome's Latin translation. The ancient and immediate versions are distinct from those translations derived from an intermediate translation such as the Old Latin which was translated from a Greek version, and modern translations made from critical editions. The ancient and immediate versions must themselves be subjected to text criticism, and then the evidence each presents with regard to the Hebrew text must be examined.
Psalm 110:1 presents a text which gives the opportunity to do detailed textual study. Variants occur at all levels--the medieval manuscripts, the ancient and immediate versions, and one area which has not been given attention, the text according to the New Testament references. Christian scholars have generally regarded the New Testament quotations as taken from "the Septuagint" and as such of no value in understanding the text of the Hebrew Bible. When the NT does not agree with the institutionalized "Septuagint," this is generally regarded a paraphrase. Hebrew Bible scholars, including Tov, have largely ignored the NT as a source of information about the Hebrew text.
I am arguing that this point of view needs to be reevaluated as the New Testament quotations should be regarded as ancient and immediate versions separate from the "Septuagint." |
| |
top
| Yehudah Kraut |
"Deciphering the "Shema": A New Approach to Deuteronomy 6:4" |
yehudakraut@hotmail.com |
| Despite its deceptively simple constituent words and centrality in Jewish liturgy, Deuteronomy 6:4 (the "Shema") has long confounded biblical interpreters. A literal rendering of the verse yields an elusive statement -- "Listen Israel Yah-weh our God Yah-weh one" -- that appears muddled or redundant. Most exegetical solutions to Deuteronomy 6:4 belong to one of two major categories. The first would solve the syntactic problem utilizing customary rules of biblical Hebrew grammar; the second would recast the sentence into a statement exhibiting unique grammatical features. Neither approach, however, produces a compelling result: the standard solutions all encounter some syntactic difficulty, while the more radical interpretations appear forced or artificial. I would contend that the confusion stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of the verse's literary structure. Deuteronomy 6:4b represents an example of the AB/AC structure often referred to as "staircase parallelism." If the verse is understood in this way, much of the difficulty disappears, and its semantic meaning -- expressed in poetic syntax -- becomes apparent: "Yah-weh our God is one." Two closely comparable verses, Exodus 15:3 and Hosea 12:6, provide solid precedent for the attempt to locate staircase parallelism in our verse. A number of additional verses (e.g. Judges 4:18) demonstrate that biblical narrative -- not just biblical poetry -- makes use of staircase parallelism. I show, moreover, that staircase parallelism serves a communicative function well-suited to Deuteronomy 6:4. Throughout the Bible, staircase parallelism most often introduces a speech (or speaker). Deuteronomy 6:4-9 marks the beginning of Moses?fs lengthy exposition of the Law; indeed, Tigay notes, "As the first paragraph of the Instruction that God gave Moses?cit is, in a sense, the beginning of Deuteronomy proper." Given its critical position introducing the main body of the book, the verse employs staircase parallelism as a rhetorical device that elevates and draws attention to its lofty message. |
| |
top
| Yehudah Kraut |
"The Birds and the Babes: the Structure and Meaning of Psalm 8" |
yehudakraut@hotmail.com |
| Psalm 8 poses a number of notoriously difficult exegetical challenges. In their interpretations, scholars have often resorted to speculative exegesis more so than in compelling textual argument -- suggesting, for example, various emendations or tenuous parallels. Yet, the efforts to interpret Psalm 8 in the light of more accessible (or hypothetical) texts have obscured the fact that the psalm possesses a particular structural and rhetorical logic. An appreciation of the psalm's structure, an elaborately conceived chiastic arrangement, elucidates three key elements of its meaning: (a) the role of 3a ("From the mouths of infants and sucklings"); (b) the identity of the "Elohim" in 6a; and (c) the overarching message of the psalm. |
| November 16, 2006 |
| Aliza Schachter |
"Princess as Political Pawn" |
|
| The account of Solomon's marriage to the daughter of an unnamed Pharaoh is often utilized as one of the components in reconstructing a broad picture of the foreign policy of the United Monarchy. Israel under David and Solomon is depicted as a major power, and indeed the Biblical text is replete with details illustrating the political capabilities of David and Solomon in the sphere of international relations. As is often the case, however, the nature of the Biblical material limits our ability to gain a full understanding of these conventions, and a fuller picture can be constructed only on the basis of sources from the surrounding civilizations. While there are no contemporaneous 10th century texts to corroborate the details of the Biblical accounts, there are a variety of diplomatic texts from throughout the Near East that can serve as parallels to the diplomatic practice described. In particular, an Akkadian juridical text from Ugarit can help elucidate the episode of the unparalleled marriage of Solomon and the Pharaoh's daughter. An interesting detail of the marriage arrangement is the land grant of the city of Gezer given by the Pharaoh to his daughter, presumably as a dowry. While real estate is well-attested as an important element of dowries throughout the Near East, the text from Ugarit offers a precise parallel in that it records a town given to the daughter of the king upon her marriage. I believe that the details surrounding this transfer help clarify a difficult word in the Biblical text as well as provide insight into the overall political significance of the marriage. |
| |
| Susan Zeelander |
"Discerning Biblical Religion, methodology of Professor Stephen A. Geller" |
zeelande@sas.upenn.edu |
| Biblical religion is discerned by Professor Stephen A. Geller by combining a literary approach with an historical orientation. The biblical writers did not systematically present their arguments, but used literary methods to achieve their goals. Deuteronomic, priestly, wisdom and prophetic traditions sometimes conflict, and sometimes complement each other. By using the full range of scholarly disciplines, textual criticism, philology, and attention to such factors as possible composite authorship, mixture of genres, and comparative evidence, Geller demonstrates how the ancient writers polemically expressed their beliefs. His methods and textual examples are presented in Sacred Enigmas: Literary Religion in the Hebrew Bible (1996: Routledge). The priestly writer, for example, did not overtly express his theology but did so indirectly through a series of covenants, beginning with the Noahide covenant in Genesis 9, the rainbow sign and continuing through the descriptions of the mishkan. P's juxtaposition of Shabbat and shrine in Ex 31 and Ex 35 help explain P's larger intent, that is, to demonstrate Shabbatt's sign as a link between the shrine and creation. In Sacred Enigmas, Geller honors the tradition of Hermann Gunkel as he recreates "the essential emotional and aesthetic factors that alone can make a text live again in the minds of contemporary readers (vii). |
| |
top
| Susan Zeelander |
"Inner Biblical Polemics and Psalm 50" |
zeelande@sas.upenn.edu |
Scholarly literature suggests that Psalm 50 was part of the formal cult worship in Jerusalem, based on form criticism and analogies from other ancient Near Eastern cultures (Kraus, Psalms 1-59,488-491). But, if the psalm was used as part of a festival liturgy then why would it disparage the regular burnt offering sacrifices which were part of the support system for the cult. If the occasion was a covenant renewal ceremony why would it focus on reproof and not celebration?
A close reading of the psalms' literary markers and dynamics suggest that the writer guardedly sets forth a basis for a revised relationship with God. It is an individualized approach that reflects ideas and motifs found in lament psalms of the individual, in Deuteronomy, and in covenant language. The psalmist acknowledges the seriousness and controversy of his subject by presenting it in the context of a revelation and by using the authenticating language of Sinai (now moved to Zion as the prophetic texts have done). He disingenuously says "Not regarding your sacrificial offerings do I rebuke you," but then simplifies and twists priestly ideas of sacrifice. Perhaps echoing the term kabod, which in 1st temple period priestly writings signifies the presence of God in the sanctuary, the writer uses the unusual term kabbed when God asks that the people 'honor' him (verse 15). As the psalmist completes God's rebuke of the people at the end of the psalm the individual has been challenged to make a total commitment to God. Then, when he is in need he will "call out" to God, the only one who can save. |
| |
top
| Bill Zimmerle |
"Second Impressions: The Iconography of Hebrew Seals" |
zimmerle@sas.upenn.edu |
This workshop will survey the different types of Hebrew seals by analyzing their iconography and paleography. Special consideration will be given to epigraphic features, iconographic motifs and borrowings, and the criteria for classifying Northwest Semitic seals. Participants will learn how to evaluate seal impressions and incorporate such an analysis into their research on Syro-Palestinian archaeology and the Bible. |
| April 20, 2004 |
top
| Paul Delnero |
"Textual Criticism and Sumerian Literature" |
delnero@sas.upenn.edu |
As with many Biblical and Classical texts, Sumerian literary compositions must be reconstructed from copies that were compiled at a later date than the texts they contain were originally composed. Since the original versions of these texts are never preserved, the reconstruction of these texts requires a text critical methodology for determining the extent to which the preserved duplicates are accurate and reliable, and for deciding when and how they should be emended when they appear to contain errors. In this paper, the text critical methods that have been developed for evaluating biblical manuscripts will be examined as an empirical model for reconstructing Sumerian literary compositions. |
| 2001 |
top
| Shalom Holtz |
"To Go and Marry any Man that You Please: The History of a Legal Idiom" |
holtz@sas.upenn.edu |
The "essential formula" of the rabbinic writ of divorce is a phrase that
releases the woman "to go and marry any man that you please." This phrase
has antecedents in Aramaic marriage contracts from Elephantine and can be
traced back to originally Akkadian formulations. [This paper was published
in JNES 2001]. |
| |
| Shalom Holtz |
"Judiciary in Mesopotamia During the Period of Persian Domination" |
holtz@sas.upenn.edu |
Students of Mesopotamian culture in the 1st millennium BC, in general, and of law, in particular, have noted that the transition between native Babylonian rule and Persian hegemony did not affect the legal culture. The proposed paper will illustrate this continuity by examining the administration of justice, particularly through the office of royal judge.
From its very beginnings, the ideology of Mesopotamian kingship has placed great emphasis on the role of the monarch as 'king of justice'. In the Neo-Babylonian period, the office of 'judges of the king' (dayyanu sa sarri) concretizes this ideological association between the
king and the courts of law. In her study Die Richter des Nabonid (AOAT
252, pp. 557-595), Cornelia Wunsch collects the names of the different
men who served in judicial councils (Richterkollegien) as 'judges of
Nabonidus' and describes their office. Wunsch herself notes that some of
the judges of Nabonidus continue their service as judges of Cyrus.
The proposed study will build on Wunsch's observations by examining the
office of royal judge during the reigns of Cyrus, Cambyses and Darius I. It will present the evidence available from the cuneiform archives of both private families and temples in Achaemenid Babylon, Sippar and Uruk. In doing so, it hopes to shed descriptive light on the judiciary in Mesopotamia during the period of Persian domination. |
| |
| Joshua Jeffers |
""Fifth Campaign Reliefs in Sennacherib's Palace Without
Rival' at Nineveh" |
jeffers@sas.upenn.edu |
The palace reliefs of Sennacherib were extensively studied in J. Russell's seminal book, Sennacherib's Palace Without Rival at Nineveh. He concluded that all the relief programs in the palace depicted events from the first three of Sennacherib's campaigns to Babylonia, Elam, and Palestine, respectively. However, in 1994 E. Frahm successfully reconstructed a heavily damaged epigraph in the throneroom which specifically mentions the city of Ukku and its ruler Manijae. We know from Sennacherib's annals that Ukku was one of the targets of his fifth campaign, which also included an incursion on those dwelling on Mt. Nippur--both military events were located to the north of Nineveh in the Zagros mountain range. With this as a starting point, I reexamined the palace reliefs in order to identify other programs that may reference this campaign which had previously been overlooked. Based on considerations of geography, architecture, flora, the depiction of foreigners, and the purpose of the campaigns as described in the annals, I argue that the reliefs in room XXXVIII, room XLVIII, and the reliefs on the western wall of room I (the throneroom) contain representations of military activities from Sennacherib's fifth campaign to the North. |
| October 26, 2006 |
top
| Stephen Kim |
"Semitic N-Stem" |
stephensbkim@yahoo.com |
This paper argues that the prefix n, which is characteristic in the Semitic N-stem, is related to the central meaning of the stem. It consists of three parts: 1. the historical development of the three allomorphs of the prefix, na, n, and hin; 2. the pronominal background of the prefix n in Biblical Hebrew, the Semitic languages, and the bigger language group of Afro-Asiatic phylum; 3. the central meaning of the Semitic N-stem.
This paper concludes that the subject or the object of the base construction is expressed in the Semitic N-stem by the n-morpheme, and that the central meaning of the N-stem as the middle is related to the characteristic n-prefix of the stem. It follows that the subject or the object of the G-stem is expressed vaguely in the N-stem and ignored by the speaker, focusing on the remaining referent only.
In the course of time, the linguistic development of the passive from the middle voice in the Indo-European languages occurred in the Semitic languages as well. Thus, even though the doer of the action had already been noted in the verb itself, the agent in the Niphal passive came to be specified by mans of a prepositional phrase in b (Deut 33:29), l (Gen 31:15) or min (Gen 9:11). However, the central function of the middle is preserved even in the developed passive voice of the Semitic N-stem. As Steven Boyd said, "the difference between middles and passives is the presence of an external agent in the semantic structure in passive constructions." |
| |
| Stephen Kim |
"Thoru-Ilu, the Fertility God of Ugarit" |
stephensbkim@yahoo.com |
Ilu is the highest god of Ugarit. Like other kings of gods, he has many epithets. One of the most frequently used epithets is Thoru (toru). It seems that there are two well represented competing views about the ancient Near Eastern symbolism of the bull. According to the one, the title tr signifies that Ilu is a fertility god. The other view is that the ancient bull symbolizes the strength and might of Ilu, rather than fertility. This paper begins with the Held's methodological principle zero, "all internal Biblical evidence must first be examined exhaustively before even beginning the
philological investigation of the comparative Semitic evidence for the word in question." According to this principle, this paper examines all internal Ugaritic evidence first before making inferences. The consequence of a thorough scrutiny of the Ugaritic literary data is that Ilu?fs epithet Thoru indicates that Ilu is a fertility god of Ugarit. Bull symbolizes might or strength in other areas of the ancient Near East and beyond, but when the epithet is used to describe Ilu of Ugarit, it consistently signifies the aspect of fertility of the highest god of the city. |
| December 7, 2006 |
| Stephen Kim |
"Traveling Gods in Ancient
Syria-Palestine" |
stephensbkim@yahoo.com |
This paper explores the divine travels and their
religious and cultural significance. According to the
extant bodies of literature, they venerated the god
Ilu as the highest god in the ancient Syrian state of
Ugarit, while the Israelites worshiped YHWH as the God Most High. Many scholars maintain that Ilu of Ugarit
was the original god of the Israelites, who pronounced
his name El in the southern dialect, before YHWH
appropriated his status and traits. In this theory,
the identification of Ilu with El is taken for
granted.
The travel of gods sheds new light on the issue. In Ugarit, when a particular deity travels, it is a mark
of his/her rank in the pantheon. The messenger gods
who travel the most usually belong to the lowest rank,
while the highest god, Ilu, most often sits enthroned and is honored by the deities who visit him. In
Israel, YHWH is also represented as sitting on the
highest throne. However, unlike Ilu of Ugarit, he
himself travels before his people in the wilderness,
leading them to the Promised Land and beyond. On the
other hand, El of Israel also travels throughout the
Levant and even down into Egypt. Therefore, the
traveling pattern of El of Israel is similar to that
of YHWH, but at variance with that of Ilu of Ugarit.
This study will provide a new piece of evidence that
should be taken into consideration. |
| February 13, 2007 |
| Shannon Martino |
"Alternate Representational Systems: Vinca Cultural Priorities from the 6th- mid 4th millennium B.C." |
sacorbit@gmail.com |
For many years, Mesopotamia was thought to be the birthplace of writing, though often others had tried to illustrate the early development of Indus or Egyptian writing traditions. Since 1963 however, Transylvania in southern Romania, has tried to claim its right to be called the earliest location of writing. Initial finds date from the 6th millennium B.C. and were excavated at the site of Tartaria. The writing found on the few Tartaria Tablets as well as figurines and spindle whorls is known as Old European, but questions remain as to whether this script should be considered writing. What we may more easily and confidently be convinced of, is that the signs found on these tablets and other objects from the Vinca culture are comparable to the early economic signs of Mesopotamia. At the same time, these signs stem from an entirely different motivation than the Mesopotamian system and stop being used during the mid 4th millennium. Rather than having an economic motivation, Old European signs are mostly associated with objects having ritual and domestic connotations. Yet these items remain obscure in the fields of early writing and additional analyses of the objects involved are needed in order to more clearly understand the role of signs in Vincan practices and daily life. The three main questions still to be answered are: "Are these signs a script?", "Does there need to be an economic impetus for the creation of a representational system?", and "Why did this language never seem to evolve into the type of writing used in Mesopotamia?". |
| April 25, 2006 |
top
| Kevin McGeough |
"Late Bronze Age Administration: Keeping Track of People" |
kmcgeough@hotmail.com |
Understanding the administrative system used by ancient people is fundamental to understanding many other aspects of their lives, including social differentiation, social organization, craft specialization and production. The results of administration are often easily recognizable in the archaeological record - any kind of monumental architecture being an obvious example. However, it is often more difficult to determine (and find scholarly consensus on) the nature of this administration. For example, the previous decade saw major disagreements about the nature of Egyptian New Kingdom administration in the Southern Levant. The archaeological evidence has proven indecisive in determining the degree of influence wielded by Egyptians in the Late Bronze Age Levant. Yet no matter how ephemeral this topic, administration remains an important topic in the reconstruction of the lives of ancient people. The manner in which people organize themselves lies at the heart of many issues of self- identification and the active participation in society. Sites like Late Bronze Age Ugarit, which have a wealth of material culture and textual remains are perfect areas for the study of this topic. Readable texts, which refer to aspects of organization, as well as traditional archaeological evidence, can be integrated to create a better understanding of ancient administrative systems. Archaeological and textual evidence is available for both the external and internal aspects of administration at Ugarit, which can shed light on aspects of administration throughout the Near East in the Late Bronze Age. |
| |
| Matthew Rutz |
"The Stele in and out of Cultic Contexts in Bronze Age Syria: Signs of Authority at Emar and Ekalte" |
mrutz@sas.upenn.edu |
The stelae from Bronze Age Syria provide a potentially fruitful perspective from which to view ancient Syrian religious ideologies and practices, since these objects have been identified in both the archaeological and epigraphic records. This paper will concentrate on a holistic reading of the Late Bronze artifacts and documents, since these sources exhibit the widest distribution of archaeological contexts and literary genres.
A stele is a physical, public mediator of social discourse. As such, it is a visible sign and locus of the negotiation of changing power relations among gods, ruling elites, and the general population. This paper will contend that each context in which a stele appears necessarily implies all of its other contexts. |
| October 30, 2003 |
top
| Karen Sonik |
"The Dragon-Green, the Luminous, the Dark, the Serpent-Haunted Sea: Tikva Frymer-Kensky's Non-Domesticated Woman" |
karen.sonik@gmail.com |
In her seminal 1992 book In the Wake of the Goddesses: Women, Culture and the Biblical Transformation of Pagan Myth, Tikva Frymer-Kensky offered a compelling examination of the role of gender in the development of the Mesopotamian pantheon. Her thesis, that goddesses in particular declined significantly over the course of the late third and the second millennium, has generally been accepted although scholars such as Michalowski have suggested this decline represented the convergence of many local, independent processes rather than a single unified trend. This paper considers the nature of Inana/Ishtar, whom Frymer-Kensky identified both as a "fearsome admonition of the dangers of the unencumbered woman" and as the primary exception to the general decline she proposed, alongside that of the powerful figure of Tiamat. |
| May 1, 2007 |
top
| Karen Sonik |
"Parables of Kingship: A Literary Text in Ritual Context" |
karen.sonik@gmail.com |
The late second-millennium composition Enuma elis ("when on high"), known for decades as the Babylonian Creation Epic, is now known primarily as a political myth intended to support Babylon's claim as foremost among cities and to justify the elevation of its patron god, Marduk, to the head of the Mesopotamian pantheon. Marduk's just kingship is, however, preceded by - and contrasted with - at least two other models of divine rulership in the epic. The depictions of rulership in Enuma elis are considered in the context of the akitu festival. |
| May 1, 2007 |
top
| Ran Zadok |
"Connections Between Babylonia and Elam in the Chaldean and Achaemenid Periods"" |
zadokr@post.tau.ac.il |
The paper discusses the political and economic connections between Babylonia and Elam during the periods of the Neo- Babylonian and Achaemenid empires (626-539 and 538-332 BCE respectively). It is based on both published and unpublished sources in Neo/Late-Babylonian as well as in Neo-Elamite and Royal Achaemenid Elamite. These are mostly implicit, as pertinent chronicles and royal inscriptions are rare. Therefore the evidence for political history is minimal whereas the socio-economic information is much more detailed. Nevertheless, even this information is chronologically uneven as most of it refers to the Chaldaean and early Achaemenid period with very few sources about the late Achaemenid period (483-332 BCE). An appendix is devoted to workmen from upper Mesopotamia and Syria ('Assyrians') in Elam including Arabians. They were--at least partly-- subjects of the Neo-Babylonian empire before its demise. |
| 2006 |
| Menachem Ben-Sasson |
"The Un-Finished Story of the Keter (A Few Chapters from the History of the Aleppo Codex)" |
|
Exactly 60 years ago this week the synagogue in Aleppo was attacked in riots that broke out in response to the UN decision on the partition of Palestine (Nov. 29, 1947).
Among the items damaged in those riots was the Aleppo Codex, a new fragment of which reached the Ben-Zvi Institute this month. The fragment, a small piece of parchment containing verses from Exodus 8 (the plagues of Egypt) was donated by the Samuel and Clara Sabbagh family. The late Samuel Sabbagh, born in Aleppo, picked up the fragment from the floor of the synagogue in Aleppo just after the riots. Mr. Sabbagh kept the fragment in his wallet as an amulet until his death in Brooklyn in 2000.
The Sabbagh family has donated the fragment to the Ben-Zvi Institute, which is responsible for the Aleppo Codex. That codex, known in Hebrew as Keter Aram Zova, is the most reliable source for the Masoretic text of the Bible. Written in Tiberias in the tenth century, it was kept in Jerusalem, looted during the Crusades and ransomed in Egypt, where Maimonides consulted it for the writing of Torah scrolls. Eventually it was taken to Aleppo, presumably by a grandson of Maimonides and preserved in the synagogue there until the riots in 1947.
A Syrian Jew, Mordechai Faham, brought the manuscript out of Syria and to Israel in 1957 and presented it to Izhak Ben-Zvi, the second President of the State of Israel. It was entrusted to the Ben-Zvi Institute. The manuscript was restored at the Israel Museum and is displayed in the Shrine of the Book along with the Dead Sea Scrolls.
About one third of the manuscript is missing and there are various theories regarding what happened to the missing parts -- perhaps damaged in fire or taken by individuals. One page (from Chronicles) was discovered a few decades ago when a woman from Brooklyn brought it to the Jewish National and University Library in Jerusalem and it was immediately identified.
The Ben-Zvi Institute hopes that more people will come forward with fragments of the Aleppo Codex, one of the most important medieval Hebrew manuscripts in the world. |
| December 11, 2003 |
top
| Naftali Cohn |
"The Earliest Rabbis and Their Claim for Authority: An Analysis of the Ritual Narrative Genre in the Mishnah" |
ncohn@alcor.concordia.ca |
In their accounts of ritual performed in the Temple when it still
stood, the rabbis of the Mishnah narrate the rituals in ways that
differ from earlier accounts of the same ritual. The rabbis, for
example, repeatedly emphasize entry into and exit out of the Temple's
sacred space, ritualizing these actions and thus constructing the
boundaries of an imagined Temple. The rabbis also repeatedly
construct the court of Temple times, a judicial body, as the ultimate
authority over Temple ritual. Each of these rabbinic innovations, it
is argued, express a claim for rabbinic authority over the Temple and
its ritual and over ritual in post-Temple times. These claims for
authority are especially significant in light of the growing consensus
that the rabbis were a small group who did not have political or
ritual authority at the time. |
| January 23, 2007 |
| Michael Carasik |
"Translating the Miqra'ot Gedolot into English" |
mcarasik@sas.upenn.edu |
"The Commentators' Bible" -- Michael Carasik presented a summary of his work on The Commentators' Bible, his project to create an English-language version of the traditional Jewish Bible commentaries called "Miqra'ot Gedolot." The first volume is Exodus. He described the page layout and explained the choice of commentators and of the two English translations. One translation is more literal, the other is freer. The presence of both demonstrate that the Hebrew text is central to his work. He also described the translation method, an imaginative rendering of what the commentator would write today in contemporary English for an audience that knows little or no Hebrew. |
| April 24, 2002 |
| Nili Fox |
Academic Life Beyond the Dissertation |
nfox@cn.huc.edu |
| You CAN land an academic position with a Ph.D. from AMES/NELC. Tips on
surviving and succeeding in your new position: turning your dissertation into a
book; what to expect from reviewers; joining your new colleagues as a team
player with integrity; sailing through reappointments and promotions towards
tenure. |
| March 2, 2004 |
|
 |
| Judah Goldin (1914-1998) |

|