One strand of
discussion under this general heading concerned
how good a job graduate schools do preparing people to be teachers
as opposed to researchers. Jennifer Sheridan picked up on this theme,
noting that her own training did not prepare her for her current job
in any direct way: whereas she spent most of her time in graduate
school (at Columbia) learning to do research in Roman economic
history, she now teaches five undergraduate courses per semester at
St. Joe's and has little opportunity to do research or to integrate
into her teaching what little research she has time for. She now feels
she would like to have had more instruction in course preparation,
pedagogical technique, etc. Jacqui
Sadashige noted that most graduate students she knows do quite a lot of
teaching and thus by the time they get their degrees have had
quite a lot of teaching experience, a point with which others
agreed. Nevertheless, there seemed to be general agreement that,
while graduate school does require graduate students to begin
their pedagogical careers, they tend to do so in a relatively
unstructured way, without a great deal of guidance.
Andr
Joe Farrell asked whether those present would favor a
recommendation that graduate programs adjust their focus towards
pedagogical apprenticeship at the expense of research training.
The group expressed a clear disinclination to endorse any such
recommendation. Alessandro Schiessaro suggested that, in fact,
most people go to graduate school precisely because they want to
learn to do independent research in a field and, if they plan to
seek related employment, to find a position that will allow them
to do such research. Judy Hallett called the dichotomy a false
one, and said that we should in fact be doing more to bring our
research into the undergraduate classroom and to encourage
undergraduates to undertake serious research projects,
particularly those of a collaborative nature, and she cited some
examples in which she had seen this approach work.
[To proceed to section 2.2, click
here.]